MADRID — A Spanish Catholic priest is facing the prospect of prison time over remarks he made nearly a decade ago regarding Islam, reigniting debate about freedom of expression and the treatment of Christians in Europe.
Father Custodio Ballester, a priest in Spain, could face up to three years behind bars, along with fines, after being charged with “Islamophobia,” according to a report from The Christian Broadcasting Network (CBN). The case stems from comments Ballester made in 2016 and later expanded upon in a 2017 YouTube video.
The controversy began when Ballester responded to a question about interfaith dialogue between Christians and Muslims. In a letter, he wrote: “This renewed revival of Christian-Muslim dialogue, paralyzed by the alleged ‘imprudence’ of the beloved Benedict XVI, is far from a reality. Islam does not allow for dialogue. You either believe or you are an infidel who must be subdued one way or another.”
Father Custodio Ballester, a 61-year-old Spanish Catholic priest, appeared in court today, facing a possible three-year prison sentence for his criticism of radical jihadism, having been accused of Islamophobia.
Info: El Mundo pic.twitter.com/ex5nHEoemr
— Sachin Jose (@Sachinettiyil) October 1, 2025
In the following year, Ballester elaborated on his perspective, warning that Islam posed a threat in Europe and that Christians in many Muslim-majority countries faced persecution. While observers note that his comments were a factual assessment of global religious persecution, they drew the ire of the Association of Spanish Muslims Against Islamophobia, which filed a complaint that ultimately led to legal charges against both Ballester and a journalist.
The trial took place on October 1, and Ballester currently awaits the court’s verdict. Should he be sentenced to prison, he has stated that he intends to appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.
For Ballester, the stakes go far beyond his personal freedom. “The survival of freedom of expression in today’s Spain depends on the ruling in this case,” he told the Catholic News Agency. “Otherwise, we’ll be headed toward a new Cuban dictatorship — one where you are arrested not only for what you say but for what you think, if it differs from what Fidel Castro decided.”
Despite the gravity of the situation, Ballester has maintained remarkable composure, which he attributes in part to his military background. “In the Spanish army’s special forces, we used to say: ‘Prepare for the worst. The easy stuff has already been planned for,’” he told the Catholic News Agency. “That’s why I’m calm. If everything goes well, I’ll be even happier.”
The unfolding case has drawn international attention, raising questions about religious freedom, free speech, and the limits of political correctness in modern Europe.
CBN continues to cover developments in the case.